Photo: Getty Images

Last week, PEOPLE named John Krasinski their Sexiest Man Alive for 2024.

In honor of the exciting news, The Bobby Bones Show had listeners put together their list for sexiest men in country music. Amy and Morgan were put to the test to see if they could name all of the top contenders. Both of their first guesses didn’t make the list: George Strait and Warren Zeiders. After that, they were able to knock down a few each, but neither were able to guess Parker McCollum, Kenny Chesney, or Jake Owen.

Here is the complete listener list!

  1. Riley Green
  2. Sam Hunt
  3. Morgan Wallen
  4. Tim McGraw
  5. Keith Urban
  6. Parker McCollum
  7. Kenny Chesney
  8. Jake Owen
  9. Blake Shelton